Advice on which system to replace my Eero with

Advice on which system to replace my Eero with

Advice on which system to replace my Eero with
Advice on which system to replace my Eero with
a week ago - last edited a week ago

Hello all,

I'm looking to replace my existing Eero 6 Pro mesh network, and wanted advice about which Deco system to buy for my needs.

 

My existing system is 3 x Eero6 wifi units + 2 x Eero6 extenders.  The main problem I have with Eero is that I cannot direct my devices to connect to specific nodes, with the result being that every time Eero restarts (normally their monthly update), the pods come online at different times and devices try to connect to whatever is on first ... with the result being that some devices end up connected to pods so far away that the service is unusable.  The system/devices don't self-correct and I end up with a Google camera that can't connect, or Nest thermostats that are laggy.  I can correct the issue to some degree by turning devices or nodes on/off, but even then it's like playing whack a mole, not to mention a giant pita for something you want to plug in and forget.  I never get an optimal wifi experience for all my devices despite have a strong mesh that covers all corners of my home.

 

My understanding is that the Deco series will allow me to direct what node a device connects to.  Assuming this is correct, then I need to decide which Deco to replace my existing system with.

 

About my home.  I live in a large 2 story condo of about 2,000 Sqft.  Normally you could service this with 1 or 2 pods, but there are thick concrete walls in spots, so I believe I need 3 pods at least (although it took 5 from Eero placed very specifically to get full coverage).  I'd love to use as few pods as possible, but not at the expense of quality wifi.  If I need more to ensure amazing wifi, that is ok and I'd rather pay the extra cost if needed.

 

Anyone able to suggest which Deco's might best suit my needs?  Many thanks and cheers - P.

  0      
  0      
#1
Options
2 Accepted Solutions
Re:Advice on which system to replace my Eero with-Solution
a week ago - last edited a week ago

  @Lyphe416 

 

I am moving from Deco to Eero. 

Take what you will from that.

 

Deco works the same way as Eero. The difference is that you can try to tell Deco to connect certain devices to specific nodes, but sadly it doesn't mean it actually will. If Deco wants to connect a device to a different node than you have selected, it will. Nothing you do will change that.

 

Sorry about that, but you may as well know the truth.

Recommended Solution
  0  
  0  
#4
Options
Re:Advice on which system to replace my Eero with-Solution
a week ago - last edited a week ago

  @Lyphe416 

 

The only reason I went for Deco is the X50-Outdoor node, but I've got around the need for that now so its out with Deco.

 

Check out some of the other threads. So many problems out there. Sadly TP-Link have too large a portfolio that they cannot keep up with their own products and associated issues.

 

One of the biggest lies is all Decos work together. Well, yes, but you get the lowest common denominator. So if you have three different models, you get the features of the lowest quality model. Until they update the firmware for the remainder, and there is no guarantee they ever will.

 

My network is X50 and X50-Outdoor. The same model, but the Outdoor node isn't the same firmware platform as the X50, so the features on the X50 do not appear on the app because the X50-Outdoor doesn't support them.

 

Glad I caught you before you spent good money only to find out the truth.

 

Oh, and support is terrible. If you have a problem they can't sort out, they just go quiet. Have a search, you will see plenty of comments on that too!

 

Good luck.

Recommended Solution
  0  
  0  
#6
Options
5 Reply
Re:Advice on which system to replace my Eero with
a week ago

  @Lyphe416 Hi, welcome to the community.

How much of your network bandwidth?

Would there be any reserved Ethernet ports around the house?

 

I notice the Eero 6 is AX1800 and Deco X50 3 pack might be a nice option. Deco X50 supports Connection Preference.

 

Have you used any powerline adapters?

If yes and the house has a new deployed electric wiring system, Deco PX50 3 pack is also a great choice.

 

Thank you very much and best regards.

 

 

  0  
  0  
#2
Options
Re:Advice on which system to replace my Eero with
a week ago - last edited a week ago

Thank you David. I'm guessing that feature is the 'node/band connection preference' that I see listed in the advanced features of the X50.

Follow up question ... what do you think about the following:

 

XE75 Pro

X80

 

I think I'd move up to one of the above mesh systems, but it's hard to decide which is better since I see offsetting features in each.  I'm guessing both have the 'node/band connection preference'.  I'm leaning toward the XE75 Pro as it seems to have the best features for value, but curious what you think.

 

Ty again for any assistance.

  0  
  0  
#3
Options
Re:Advice on which system to replace my Eero with-Solution
a week ago - last edited a week ago

  @Lyphe416 

 

I am moving from Deco to Eero. 

Take what you will from that.

 

Deco works the same way as Eero. The difference is that you can try to tell Deco to connect certain devices to specific nodes, but sadly it doesn't mean it actually will. If Deco wants to connect a device to a different node than you have selected, it will. Nothing you do will change that.

 

Sorry about that, but you may as well know the truth.

Recommended Solution
  0  
  0  
#4
Options
Re:Advice on which system to replace my Eero with
a week ago - last edited a week ago

That's actually HUGELY helpful, since it is really the only reason I'd switch. Outside of that issue, Eero has been solid for me. Thanks @SteveWex 

  0  
  0  
#5
Options
Re:Advice on which system to replace my Eero with-Solution
a week ago - last edited a week ago

  @Lyphe416 

 

The only reason I went for Deco is the X50-Outdoor node, but I've got around the need for that now so its out with Deco.

 

Check out some of the other threads. So many problems out there. Sadly TP-Link have too large a portfolio that they cannot keep up with their own products and associated issues.

 

One of the biggest lies is all Decos work together. Well, yes, but you get the lowest common denominator. So if you have three different models, you get the features of the lowest quality model. Until they update the firmware for the remainder, and there is no guarantee they ever will.

 

My network is X50 and X50-Outdoor. The same model, but the Outdoor node isn't the same firmware platform as the X50, so the features on the X50 do not appear on the app because the X50-Outdoor doesn't support them.

 

Glad I caught you before you spent good money only to find out the truth.

 

Oh, and support is terrible. If you have a problem they can't sort out, they just go quiet. Have a search, you will see plenty of comments on that too!

 

Good luck.

Recommended Solution
  0  
  0  
#6
Options