@Fae Thank you for that suggestion, I changed the WANs to operate on different subnets and now I'm able to access both while connected to the Load balancer. This had worked with them on the same...

@Fae Yes, if I unplug WAN 1 then I can access the WAN 2 Admin. When I plug WAN 1 back in then I'm not able to access WAN 2 admin again.

Previously I could access both of my WAN admin pages at 192.168.2.2 and 192.168.2.3, but now only 2.2 (Wan 1) is accessible and the other is comes back as Destination host unreachable when doing ping...