Deco BE85 (BE22000) Wi-Fi 7 2-pack, my review coming from Orbi RBK50 mesh system
(I originally posted this on r/TpLink)
After 6+ years with an Orbi Wi-Fi 5 system, I decided it was time upgrade to take advantage of my AT&T 5Gbps fiber connection/LAN, and the growth of Wi-Fi 6/6E devices in my home.
I got the BE85 two pack about 5 days ago, and I need to get the big negative point out of the way, first.
The BE85 satellites have a fan that loudly runs a 5-min cycle, a few times every hour. I can tell the fan(s) run 24/7 at a very low rpm, you'd have to get your ear within one inch in a very quiet room. This is not the problem. It's the ramp to 100% that goes for apparently exactly 5 minutes, then drops back to idle speed. Happens on both satellites, so I don't think it's a hardware issue. The satellites aren't even under heavy load when the fans ramp. They just blast off, and 5 minutes later settle down.
It would be great if @Riley_S has any guidance on this. Because it's so annoying, I may have to consider returning the system.
So let's talk about the 'good stuff'. Pretty much everything else. Starting off with the OOB experience, the packaging and design is fitting of the $1000 price point. I realize this is cutting edge hardware, and I'm paying a premium for that. Right now, I think the BE85/BE95 systems appear to be the first/only mesh system with 10Gbps support and pass-through ethernet ports. No doubt this is what adds quite a bit to the premium over older TP-Link systems like the EX75 Pro, Eero and Orbi 6E competitors.
The app experience is pretty good, from initial set-up to normal usage. I use the system in Access Point mode, letting my AT&T BGW320-500 handle routing. No issues here.
There's one UI annoyance - my device names seem to have a bug, where 50% of them are designated "BSH Hausgeräte" which is somehow related to a Bosch refrigerator I recently purchased. If anyone knows how to refresh device names, I would really appreciate it.
The two pack covers my 2400sq ft home very well. The biggest difference over the Orbi system is how the Deco is able to maintain speeds at the edge of the coverage area and/or through walls. The Orbi had good coverage too, but speeds would drop significantly when you got away from line-of-sight.
I also bought the Deco X50-Outdoor. I haven't installed it just yet, as I'm trying to decide if the '5-minute fan problem' from the BE85s is going to ultimately drive me crazy.
Anyways, I'll wrap this up before it gets too longwinded, but I'm happy to answer any questions in the comments.
- Copy Link
- Subscribe
- Bookmark
- Report Inappropriate Content
Is the other end of your TP-Link 10Gbps port connected to something with a 10Gbps link rate? If it's only 1Gpbs on the other end, the negotiated rate will be 1Gbps, and the fan won't go crazy.
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
@turns2stone 2 days on 5 Gbps and 4 days on 10 Gbps; fans are incredibly quiet.
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
@Richardj186 what internet speeds are you running? Are you running wired backhaul?
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
@kellisj2003 wireless backhaul, Apple devices and various IoT. I don't have any WiFi 6e or 7 devices. WiFi speeds are averaging 750-900 Mbps via WiFi. In the Deco app, when I do the Test Internet Speed, I get speeds averaging 9.22-9.8 Gbps down and same up.
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
Discussed the fan issue with Qualcomm, who made the Pro 1220 processor which runs the routers. They suggested trying the following:
1. Unplug the routers for at least 20 minutes till they cool to room temperature.
2. Place 4 rubber feet on the bottom of the routers so that you have a half-inch to ¾-inch clearance underneath to allow for more cooling airflow underneath and inside (via the fans) the routers.
I forgot to mention I'd already done that with mine as I didn't think there was enough clearance underneath (less than a quarter inch). Maybe that's the reason my fans aren't running wild?
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
@Richardj186 I tested using the top 10gb jack instead of the bottom one for the wired backhaul node in my living room (and 1gb switch connected to the bottom 2.5gb jack). Since switching to the top 10gb, the fans haven't kicked on at all. Strange to see this, but it worked for me!
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
Tried this approach, I was able to get 3/4" clearance via some 9V batteries.
No difference, fans still spin up like crazy using the bottom 10G ethernet port. Only using the top 10G ethernet port will my fans behave like normal.
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
@turns2stone this is such a weird bug...
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
@Richardj186 What's even weirder is that A) it can be replicated by others and B) TP-Link has 'ghosted' me regarding any potential trouble-shooting or next steps. They're definitely aware of the issue and have plenty of my logs.
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
@turns2stone well hope this helps. Qualcomm thinks the issue is on their end with the Pro 1220 chip, and they're looking into a firmware fix for it. They told me they can replicate it about a third of the time, abd not always with the bottom 10 Gbps port.
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
Information
Helpful: 2
Views: 10857
Replies: 45