potential broken 2.4GHz radio on a EAP225v3
potential broken 2.4GHz radio on a EAP225v3
I have a EAP225v3 with potential broken 2.4Ghz radio (I have total 4 EAP225v3, with only 1 enabled 2.4/5GHz radio, I haven't verified this on the other 3 yet)
topology is simple
pfSense(router with vlan) <-> tp-link T1500G-10MPS switch(vlan + POE) <-> EAP225v3 <-> HP printer (just moved my printer off from my Google onhub to EAP, and this is the actually the only device connected to 2.4GHz radio)
what I discovered is every 2-3 days the printer will disconnect from EAP, and the only option for me is to delete the 2.4GHz SSID (seems will power cycle 2.4GHz radio) and recreate it, then my printer will reconnect.
so I decide to test today, my thinkpad(intel NIC) and my iPad both can "connect" to it, but nothing will work, I can sometime see DHCP assign IP to it and sometime I won't even get an IP, I tried to manually assign IP and ping gateway won't work.
However, my pixel phone is able to connect and have internet working(ping gateway etc works), and I can actually browse the web, but if I do anything putting heavy load on wifi it will disconnect, and reconnect after couple seconds.
I look at Omada controller and it shows my pixel is only getting 1Mbps connection speed
The 2.4GHz radio seems to be in some sort of power saving mode or only half working.
But on the other hand, the 5Ghz radio works very smoothly for months without any issue.
Not sure if tp-link can pull EAP information directly from Omada cloud or I can somewhat help you guys look into this locally. Thanks
- Copy Link
- Subscribe
- Bookmark
- Report Inappropriate Content
there is the situation with the devices that can't connect to the TP-Link EAP245
here it's a usb dongle Netgear WNDA3100
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
Im not from TP-Link but Netgear WNDA3100 is a 802.11n device which is really old
Sometimes these old device does not play well if you have band steering enabled( i.e. I have a withings body scale that refuse to connect to SSID that's band steering, but works fine if I give it a seperate SSID with only 2.4G enabled)
I'd recommand you create a separate SSID and only enabled 2.4G to test out your dongle. (remember not enable airtime fairness since it's causing problem as well)
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
Pascal wrote
Tried no force disociation and band steering 15,5,1 still the issues and less users are now with 5GHZ, even iPhone X stay with 2.4GHZ What I realize too, is the frequency update status managed OC200 is really slow. One user was out of the site, and I seen his device stay into client list still after 4minutes of is physical disconnection. Does any one had already face this ? and does someone tried the latest firmware OC200 with EAP330 ???
at home I use seperate SSID's for 5G and 2.4G as I never trust these band steering technologies (go look at eero(now Amazon owned) and google wifi on reddit, they are the 2 companies that's marketing automatic band sterring as their core advantage compare to traditional wifi, and see how many people's device won't connect/won't steer, and if company marketing this technology and at their size cannot do it right, it means band steering is a pure marketing hype and is a mission impossible technically, don't even dream TP-Link on this)
TLDR; use seperate SSID for 5G and 2.4G, forget about band steering, you will be glad you made this decision
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
apparently You didn't read all this topic
please review the #7 post and you will understand why this topic got the name of potential broken 2.4GHz
I already tried with separate SSID with only 2.4GHZ...
and for your information, the old Netgear dongle is 802.11n and can connect with 2.4GHZ AND 5GHZ.
no issues at all with him if we try it with an ASUS dual band wifi router ou a Cisco dual band AP.
Your advise _
to Forget the band steering and/or the FastRoaming and/or the Airtime Fairness is not a solution if we decided to invest into TP-Link with these options
_ is only an alusion or understatement to not trust TP-Link and them solutions, and will not help to resolve the issues met here.
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
I had been off-forum for a while, just saw your reply.
1. you are right about the update interval. It is not real time. But I can share you that from my experience on Omada and Meraki, they are more or less similar in the update interval design, Unifi controller is even slower. Anyway, this won't bother me so much because it is just a displaying latency.
2. For the bandsteering settings, I am sorry to know that my suggestion made the steering behavior less sensitive in your scenario.
According to your test result, tune band steering to 15,5, 3. (the higher the 3rd figure, the higher possibility to steering a client to 5GHz. My optimized number is from 3 to 5.)
3. for 2.4G, click the AP menu, 2.4Ghz bandwitdth choose "40Mhz".
If you use RSSI threshold, set the number under "-75dbm". (it is negative, be careful, I suggest to try from -75 ~ -79)
4. I still recommend upgrading the OC200 firmware, if you are not using portal function, it shouldn't cause serious issue on EAP330.
They change the SSID profile structure.
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
@pixielark Thanks for your post!
pixielark wrote
Im not from TP-Link but Netgear WNDA3100 is a 802.11n device which is really old
Sometimes these old device does not play well if you have band steering enabled( i.e. I have a withings body scale that refuse to connect to SSID that's band steering, but works fine if I give it a seperate SSID with only 2.4G enabled)
I'd recommand you create a separate SSID and only enabled 2.4G to test out your dongle. (remember not enable airtime fairness since it's causing problem as well)
I just purchased and installed a TP-Link Deco M9 Plus system in my home and have been having problems with my Withings scale ever since. I found your post. I wasn't able to find a way to create a 2nd SSID with my system, but I turned on Guest WiFi and turned 5g off of that SSID, then connected the Withings scaled to the guest WiFi and now it works great.
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
Information
Helpful: 0
Views: 7647
Replies: 17
Voters 0
No one has voted for it yet.