<
Switches
Switch T1700-G28TQ Rev2 weird behaviour with vlan acting as a hub.
This thread has been locked for further replies. You can start a new thread to share your ideas or ask questions.Switch T1700-G28TQ Rev2 weird behaviour with vlan acting as a hub.
Posts: 3
Helpful: 0
Solutions: 0
Stories: 0
Registered: 2018-03-12
2018-03-16 02:54:00
Posts: 3
Helpful: 0
Solutions: 0
Stories: 0
Registered: 2018-03-12
Switch T1700-G28TQ Rev2 weird behaviour with vlan acting as a hub.
2018-03-16 02:54:00
Tags:
Model : T1700G-28TQ
Hardware Version :
Firmware Version :
ISP :
Hello,
Firmware Version 2.0.1 Build 20170608 Rel.61525(s)
When I set up a small VLAN on my switch it behaves like a hub : All packet are sent to all ports (all ports highlightening and tcpdump on the linux gateway show LAN traffic getting in from 2 PC)
I have search for days (even trying taging source PC) but no help ... always acting as a hub with VLAN
I remove VLAN -> all is OK....
Is it a hardware problem ... or I missed some things ?
Thanks in advance for your help
Port 1 -> Linux gateway
Port 2 -> PC-Samuel
Port 13 -> PC-Salon
(all from same subnet)
Samuel
Hardware Version :
Firmware Version :
ISP :
Hello,
Firmware Version 2.0.1 Build 20170608 Rel.61525(s)
When I set up a small VLAN on my switch it behaves like a hub : All packet are sent to all ports (all ports highlightening and tcpdump on the linux gateway show LAN traffic getting in from 2 PC)
I have search for days (even trying taging source PC) but no help ... always acting as a hub with VLAN
I remove VLAN -> all is OK....
Is it a hardware problem ... or I missed some things ?
Thanks in advance for your help
Port 1 -> Linux gateway
Port 2 -> PC-Samuel
Port 13 -> PC-Salon
(all from same subnet)
Samuel
#1
Options
- Copy Link
- Subscribe
- Bookmark
- Report Inappropriate Content
Thread Manage
Announcement Manage
5 Reply
Posts: 747
Helpful: 115
Solutions: 18
Stories: 0
Registered: 2018-07-19
Re:Switch T1700-G28TQ Rev2 weird behaviour with vlan acting as a hub.
2018-03-16 17:36:54
Gateway-> PC-Samuel, the data transmit in VLAN1. PC-Samuel->gateway, the data transmit in VLAN102.
The VLAN1 hasn't the MAC of PC-Samuel, so the data forwarded to PC-Samuel will broadcast. The VLAN2 also hasn't the MAC of gateway , so the data forwarded to gateway will broadcast.
Are you confused about this?
The VLAN1 hasn't the MAC of PC-Samuel, so the data forwarded to PC-Samuel will broadcast. The VLAN2 also hasn't the MAC of gateway , so the data forwarded to gateway will broadcast.
Are you confused about this?
0
We appreciate your feedback. Feel free to let us know more. Log in to submit feedback.
0
We appreciate your feedback. Feel free to let us know more. Log in to submit feedback.
#2
Options
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
Thread Manage
Announcement Manage
Posts: 3
Helpful: 0
Solutions: 0
Stories: 0
Registered: 2018-03-12
Re:Switch T1700-G28TQ Rev2 weird behaviour with vlan acting as a hub.
2018-03-17 15:07:47
Thanks a lot for your answer.
I'm totally new to vlan. I know it filters broadcast between vlan and with different vlan subnet all trafic goes to the router. That's why I made all vlan in the same subnet and I thought broadcast would be allowed for shared ports in the same vlan .... even if this port is part of another tagged port base vlan.
In my case, with a switch in untagged port base Vlan, I thought that the switch could manage this ... beacause he knows all the end-point MAC clients.
In my case, when I make big file upload to the server (1 Gb/s), the 100 Mb notebook can't even get a DNS answer because his link is flooded.
For me it is useless to secure the Lan with Vlan if it floods my computers ... if there is no way to bypass this broadcast event.
Thanks a lot again.
I'm totally new to vlan. I know it filters broadcast between vlan and with different vlan subnet all trafic goes to the router. That's why I made all vlan in the same subnet and I thought broadcast would be allowed for shared ports in the same vlan .... even if this port is part of another tagged port base vlan.
In my case, with a switch in untagged port base Vlan, I thought that the switch could manage this ... beacause he knows all the end-point MAC clients.
In my case, when I make big file upload to the server (1 Gb/s), the 100 Mb notebook can't even get a DNS answer because his link is flooded.
For me it is useless to secure the Lan with Vlan if it floods my computers ... if there is no way to bypass this broadcast event.
Thanks a lot again.
0
We appreciate your feedback. Feel free to let us know more. Log in to submit feedback.
0
We appreciate your feedback. Feel free to let us know more. Log in to submit feedback.
#3
Options
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
Thread Manage
Announcement Manage
Posts: 4334
Helpful: 1046
Solutions: 173
Stories: 3
Registered: 2015-12-05
Re:Switch T1700-G28TQ Rev2 weird behaviour with vlan acting as a hub.
2018-03-18 01:29:13
Compte-Samy wrote
I'm totally new to vlan. I know it filters broadcast between vlan and with different vlan subnet all trafic goes to the router. That's why I made all vlan in the same subnet and I thought broadcast would be allowed for shared ports in the same vlan .... even if this port is part of another tagged port base vlan.
VLANs are a way to separate broadcast domains, not to share them between systems. If you have the same subnet spanning different VLANs, you don't need VLANs at all.
In my case, when I make big file upload to the server (1 Gb/s), the 100 Mb notebook can't even get a DNS answer because his link is flooded.
For me it is useless to secure the Lan with Vlan if it floods my computers ... if there is no way to bypass this broadcast event.
If the upload is through the router, it will slow down traffic from the notebook to the router anyway, even if you would connect the devices to the router directly.
In no way VLANs "flood computers" if set up correctly (ports 1, 2 and 13 in your setup are trunk ports, 1 and 2 even members of all VLANs, no wonder your PC gets flooded).
༺ 0100 1101 0010 10ཏ1 0010 0110 1010 1110 ༻
0
We appreciate your feedback. Feel free to let us know more. Log in to submit feedback.
0
We appreciate your feedback. Feel free to let us know more. Log in to submit feedback.
#4
Options
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
Thread Manage
Announcement Manage
Posts: 3
Helpful: 0
Solutions: 0
Stories: 0
Registered: 2018-03-12
Re:Switch T1700-G28TQ Rev2 weird behaviour with vlan acting as a hub.
2018-03-21 23:59:18
Yes I certainly misanderstand what can be do with vlan because :
- In all how-to I have readen there were nothing about IP/Subnet for making vlans
- In all how-to I have readen there were trafic shared between different vlan and a same server
That's why I though could be 'arranged' in a port-base vlan.
Thanks.
- In all how-to I have readen there were nothing about IP/Subnet for making vlans
- In all how-to I have readen there were trafic shared between different vlan and a same server
That's why I though could be 'arranged' in a port-base vlan.
Thanks.
0
We appreciate your feedback. Feel free to let us know more. Log in to submit feedback.
0
We appreciate your feedback. Feel free to let us know more. Log in to submit feedback.
#5
Options
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
Thread Manage
Announcement Manage
Posts: 4334
Helpful: 1046
Solutions: 173
Stories: 3
Registered: 2015-12-05
Re:Switch T1700-G28TQ Rev2 weird behaviour with vlan acting as a hub.
2018-03-22 00:32:31
You read the wrong how-to's. :D
Imagine VLANs as separate networks: two (or N) routers connected to two (or N) switches connected to devices. Design the topology and select unique network IP ranges for each network.
Then, if your router supports VLANs you terminate VLANs at the router. If it does not support VLANs, terminate VLANs at the switch and use different access ports to connect the switch to the router. If you design it this way, VLANs are easy to set up. Just see them as "different networks using the same (one) physical cable" between switches or between switches and routers.
Imagine VLANs as separate networks: two (or N) routers connected to two (or N) switches connected to devices. Design the topology and select unique network IP ranges for each network.
Then, if your router supports VLANs you terminate VLANs at the router. If it does not support VLANs, terminate VLANs at the switch and use different access ports to connect the switch to the router. If you design it this way, VLANs are easy to set up. Just see them as "different networks using the same (one) physical cable" between switches or between switches and routers.
༺ 0100 1101 0010 10ཏ1 0010 0110 1010 1110 ༻
0
We appreciate your feedback. Feel free to let us know more. Log in to submit feedback.
0
We appreciate your feedback. Feel free to let us know more. Log in to submit feedback.
#6
Options
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
Thread Manage
Announcement Manage
Posts: 3
Helpful: 0
Solutions: 0
Stories: 0
Registered: 2018-03-12
2018-03-16 02:54:00
Posts: 3
Helpful: 0
Solutions: 0
Stories: 0
Registered: 2018-03-12
Information
Helpful: 0
Views: 926
Replies: 5
Voters 0
No one has voted for it yet.
Tags
Report Inappropriate Content
Transfer Module
New message