AX11000 Link Aggregation with QNAP NAS

This thread has been locked for further replies. You can start a new thread to share your ideas or ask questions.
12

AX11000 Link Aggregation with QNAP NAS

This thread has been locked for further replies. You can start a new thread to share your ideas or ask questions.
20 Reply
Re:AX11000 Link Aggregation with QNAP NAS
2020-06-25 01:33:44 - last edited 2020-06-25 01:34:24

@grimmace 

 

I am  just not a fan of buying something like this and holding onto it until a manufacturer fixes the problem, as it may never happen.   Consideing their support does not even know what link aggregation is, they  won't respond to emails  and don't reply wen they say they will, I'm starting to think this is a dead end.  I'm looking at competitive models   

  0  
  0  
#13
Options
Re:AX11000 Link Aggregation with QNAP NAS
2020-06-27 19:44:31

 

 

So I've sent 8 emails and waited through 3 online sessions with technical support (on two of them, they didn't even know what link aggregation was), and there's no help at all.  I am going to check out the new Mesh system from ubiquiti. 

 

I am happy with the WIfi perofmrance and the wired lan performance, but find it odd that they can't even reply to a definiciency such as this, and the fact that my Asus AC router that I got many years ago gets more FW updates than this thing. 

 

  0  
  0  
#14
Options
Re:AX11000 Link Aggregation with QNAP NAS
2020-06-28 19:11:55

 

They sent me a beta release, it did nothing to help the problem.  I think they are just throwing stuff over without any testing or knolwedge of the issue. 

 

  0  
  0  
#15
Options
Re:AX11000 Link Aggregation with QNAP NAS
2020-07-05 20:33:19 - last edited 2020-07-05 20:33:59

TPLink senior support confirms that this router doesn't support LACP, only Static LAG, which is obviously not preferred. And that only worked with the beta release. So this router will not support LACP, which is disappointing. I have setup static LAG on my switch and will monitor the ports to see if it's actually working.

  0  
  0  
#16
Options
Re:AX11000 Link Aggregation with QNAP NAS
2020-07-31 22:05:45
Why even advertise it supports this?
  0  
  0  
#17
Options
Re:AX11000 Link Aggregation with QNAP NAS
2020-07-31 22:18:09
it is deceptive in my opinion. Plus, some of their techs don't even know what link aggregation is. I was told first it supports LACP, then that it supports only XOR mode, then finally static only mode. What a mess.
  0  
  0  
#18
Options
Re:AX11000 Link Aggregation with QNAP NAS
2020-09-02 06:00:57

@mikoz 

 

I have the same issue on AX3000/AX50.

 

I think this LAG functionality is like a shxt !

it's tasteless to eat but waste to throw away ...

 

the marketing let customer to trust beautiful dream , but tplink is like a lier.

 

damn it all, I have 4 kinds of tplink products, every each time I buy then get a bad experiment.

 

when I told me, trust again ... AX50 is so cheap and can make your deam come true..

 

I pay and get this product.....but.....

 

I don't wanna trust tplink any more. 

 

 

  0  
  0  
#19
Options
Re:AX11000 Link Aggregation with QNAP NAS
2020-09-02 06:12:49

@mikoz 

 

 

That is no any help ...

 

 

I have the same issue on AX50 product.

 

it just support static LAG and notice that - 'balance-xor'

 

I try it and set my managed switch lan port to static group (passive) , 

 

when connect Lan3 , all device and reach but bad performace about 20-30mb/s,

 

connect lan3 & lan4 , all device can't reach...(use Ping to every device) util disconnect lan3 or lan4 from switch hub ...

 

 

damn it all

 

this product as like as 

it's tasteless to eat but waste to throw away

 

 

 

 

  0  
  0  
#20
Options
Re:AX11000 Link Aggregation with QNAP NAS
2020-11-30 17:15:32

I just got an AX11000 for a review purposes and I cannot get the Link Aggregation to work with Synology DS1019+ NAS. 802.3ad definitely does not work. I cannot reach Synology after turning the AX11000's Link Aggregation on, even when I created a completely new Network Bond on DS1019+ for 2x1GBit.

Did anyone find a solution?

NAS is connected with 2x 1GBit to AX11000 to correct ports (LAN2-3). NAS shows the bond (2x 1Gbit) working fine. I can see this when I DISABLE the Link Aggregation from the AX11000. As soon as I turn the link aggregation on from AX11000, I cannot connect to the NAS at all. This is a core feature for a device in this price category. You definitely want to up your LAN speed to 1Gbit to 2Gbit to serve multiple devices in the LAN from the NAS.

I had no issues with Asus RT-AC88U-router. This certainly does not bode well for a 400€ device like AX11000.

  1  
  1  
#21
Options
Re:AX11000 Link Aggregation with QNAP NAS
2021-08-24 15:49:07

 

Fex wrote

I just got an AX11000 for a review purposes and I cannot get the Link Aggregation to work with Synology DS1019+ NAS. 802.3ad definitely does not work. I cannot reach Synology after turning the AX11000's Link Aggregation on, even when I created a completely new Network Bond on DS1019+ for 2x1GBit.

Did anyone find a solution?

NAS is connected with 2x 1GBit to AX11000 to correct ports (LAN2-3). NAS shows the bond (2x 1Gbit) working fine. I can see this when I DISABLE the Link Aggregation from the AX11000. As soon as I turn the link aggregation on from AX11000, I cannot connect to the NAS at all. This is a core feature for a device in this price category. You definitely want to up your LAN speed to 1Gbit to 2Gbit to serve multiple devices in the LAN from the NAS.

I had no issues with Asus RT-AC88U-router. This certainly does not bode well for a 400€ device like AX11000.

@Fex Not that this helps, but I use a Netgear switch (Netgear GS110TP) to handle the Link Aggregation to my QNAP NAS (TS-253A).  I too had an ASUS router (RT-AC3200) that I was using prior to the TP-Link - however, that router did not support LAG and necessitated the need to use the aforementioned switch.  When I switched over to the TP-Link - I tried to eschew the Netgear and run everything through the TP-Link (AX11000).... yeah..., suffice it to say that I spent quite a few days getting my network back up and running with the switch, TP-Link, and NAS (to be honest, I did try to use IPV6 somewhere in there and that really FUBAR'd some things up as well...).

I am having my own issues with FTP Port Forwarding not working between my NAS and the AX11000 from an external network (but worked just fine when I used my ASUS router...)

  0  
  0  
#22
Options