EAP225-Outdoor(Canada) - no firmware from official website can be installed (fails validation)

This thread has been locked for further replies. You can start a new thread to share your ideas or ask questions.

EAP225-Outdoor(Canada) - no firmware from official website can be installed (fails validation)

This thread has been locked for further replies. You can start a new thread to share your ideas or ask questions.
EAP225-Outdoor(Canada) - no firmware from official website can be installed (fails validation)
EAP225-Outdoor(Canada) - no firmware from official website can be installed (fails validation)
2020-02-24 19:06:57 - last edited 2020-02-24 19:13:24
Model: EAP225-Outdoor  
Hardware Version: V1
Firmware Version: 1.5.0 Build 20190603 Rel. 66761

All firmwares listed on EAP225-Outdoor Canadian page ( https://www.tp-link.com/ca/support/download/eap225-outdoor/#Firmware ) are US firmwares which fail to install on a Canadian version of EAP225-Outdoor.

 

At the time of writing all firmwares listed are:

  • EAP225-Outdoor(US)_V1_1.6.1 Build 20191022
  • EAP225-Outdoor(US)_V1_1.6.0 Build 20190722
  • EAP225-Outdoor(US)_V1_1.5.0 Build 20190404

 

all are US and fail validation when you try to install them

  0      
  0      
#1
Options
7 Reply
Re:EAP225-Outdoor(Canada) - no firmware from official website can be installed (fails validation)
2020-02-26 00:38:14

@c2h5oh 

 

According to the different CA and US regulations, the US firmware is no longer applicable to CA regions (only for outdoor products), that is why your upgrade failed.
Build 20190603 is a software specially made for the CA area, and we will also make software specifically for the CA area in the future. If there is new software, we will release it to CA's official website in time.

For the firmware of the US, we will remove them from the CA official website as soon as possible. Thank you for your feedback and we are sorry for taking you inconvenience.

  0  
  0  
#2
Options
Re:EAP225-Outdoor(Canada) - no firmware from official website can be installed (fails validation)
2020-02-28 03:29:26

@forrest can we get a new build for Canada instead? There were extra fixes, including security ones released for US and EU.

 

By the way are you sure Canada and EU requires you to lock firmware to region like FCC requires in US? Cross border trade is a thing and it would be nice to be able to become compliant by using firmware for another region - the site I'm currently at has a combination of TP-Link access points for US and Canada despite the fact it's in EU..

  0  
  0  
#3
Options
Re:EAP225-Outdoor(Canada) - no firmware from official website can be installed (fails validation)
2020-02-28 14:47:35 - last edited 2020-02-28 14:48:51

@c2h5oh,

 

the U.S., Canada and the EU all have different regulatory conditions for public Radio LAN (WiFi) use in most frequency bands, especially the 5 GHz band. You can read about those differences here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_WLAN_channels#5.0_GHz_(802.11j)_WLAN

 

As for the EU, vendors are required by law to lock down the firmware for devices to be deployed in the EU according to EU regulatory conditions.

 

In the EU we can buy products that are against the law, but you are not allowed to use them. The sale is not forbidden, the use is (yes, that's quite strange).

༺ 0100 1101 0010 10ཏ1 0010 0110 1010 1110 ༻
  1  
  1  
#4
Options
Re:EAP225-Outdoor(Canada) - no firmware from official website can be installed (fails validation)
2020-03-01 20:17:48 - last edited 2020-03-01 20:18:43

@R1D2 

 

EU does not require vendors to lock down firmware right now.

 

Article 3(3)(i) of EU Radio Equipment Directive that would require firmware lockdown is not in efect - delegated acts that would list classes of devices this applies to have not been enacted yet. See the very end of Article 3 in directive 2014/53/EU.

 

The Commission expert group on Reconfigurable Radio Systems that is supposed to help European Commision to draft those delegated acts is still working and it could be years before they are done.

 

 

But going back to the original issue: since I can't install another firmware on device sold in Canadian market (RSS-247, issue 2 requires lockdown) I would love to get a new build for Canadian devices that includes security fixes present in firmwares released for EU and US markets.

  0  
  0  
#5
Options
Re:EAP225-Outdoor(Canada) - no firmware from official website can be installed (fails validation)
2020-03-01 20:23:55 - last edited 2020-03-01 20:24:16

@R1D2 

 

BTW FCC doesn't require lockdown on US devices either - in fact they have put a release clarifying that https://www.fcc.gov/news-events/blog/2015/11/12/clearing-air-wi-fi-software-updates and changed the wording of compliance documents to reflect that.

  0  
  0  
#6
Options
Re:EAP225-Outdoor(Canada) - no firmware from official website can be installed (fails validation)
2020-03-01 21:58:19 - last edited 2020-03-01 22:39:43

@c2h5oh, you might want to read article 10 (»Obligations of manufacturers«) of EU directive 2014/53/EU, which demands from vendors to ensure technical restrictions, so that their devices don't interfere with frequencies not allowed for RLAN use:

 

Quote:

1. When placing their radio equipment on the market, manufacturers shall ensure that it has been designed and 
manufactured in accordance with the essential requirements set out in Article 3
.

2. Manufacturers shall ensure that radio equipment shall be so constructed that it can be operated in at least one 
Member State without infringing applicable requirements on the use of radio spectrum.

[...]

10. In cases of restrictions on putting into service or of requirements for authorisation of use, information available 
on the packaging shall allow the identification of the Member States or the geographical area within a Member State 
where restrictions on putting into service or requirements for authorisation of use exist.

 

End quote.

 

Also note that an EU directive is not a law (the EU is not a state, thanks God!), but EU countries make their laws more or less in accordance to EU directives. Regarding RLAN use, most EU countries took over the restrictions from the german §55 Telekommunikationsgesetz (German telecommunication law), which clearly restricts the frequency range for public use of the 5 GHz RLAN band for vendors and users. Use of other frequencies is not allowed for the public and vendors must ensure that their publicly available devices can't be abused by people selecting frequencies outside this defined range (not to speak of DFS).

 

Fact is, that the german law forbids any use of frequencies outside the allowed RLAN frequency band for the public.

 

I remember that EU bureaucrats once were discussing about forcing vendors to cryptographically sign their firmwares to prevent people uploading a modified firmware. Maybe it's this discussion which you are referring to as »lock down«, then you're right: the EU countries couldn't (yet) come to an agreement about that crazy idea.

 

Of course, you could modify the software to use settings for a different regulatory domain, say to increase Tx power and/or to use frequencies the chip can handle b/c they are allowed in other countries. But if you get caught doing so by law enforcement in Germany, they will size your WLAN equipment and impose a penalty. And they will sooner or later become aware of such an abuse, e.g. if commercial or military users of the 5 GHz band notice interferences caused by an unknown device. In this case those users will inform the authorities about any troubles and the latter will send one of their measuring vehicles which will track down the troublemaker.

 

People often don't believe this, even not when they have been caught. This is a message I received months ago from an user of this forum:

 

Hi R1D2, Sorry to bother, but I have a question maybe stupid but I need to know it... Is the TL-ANT2412D antenna fixed at 12dBi gain? I had some local issues with the EIRP law and the guys told me that it has a fixed gain of 12dBi and my transmit power must be 8dBm. Is this true? Regards, XXXXXX

 

 

If you think this information is wrong, you can try to file a feature request to TP-Link to have them remove all region-specific restrictions from their firmwares. But I think such a feature request won't have any change because, for example, Pharos firmware once had been unrestricted in first releases – users could choose their region –, but this was removed in later firmware versions, maybe due to pressure from authorities or maybe due to too much abuse.

༺ 0100 1101 0010 10ཏ1 0010 0110 1010 1110 ༻
  0  
  0  
#7
Options
Re:EAP225-Outdoor(Canada) - no firmware from official website can be installed (fails validation)
2020-08-05 22:33:04

I don't understand, so many limitations... but several users made the big mistake (myself included) to flash EAP225 outdoor US version to CA version and we can't go back? why? I don't live any of those countries... I want a method to restore my US version.

 

Thanks

  0  
  0  
#8
Options